Your Fourth Amendment Rights and Probable Cause

No Comments »

Under the Fourth Amendment, the police can’t search you or seize your property without probable cause. Probable cause is commonly defined as a reasonable belief that a person has committed a crime.

Probable cause typically falls into four categories: observation, expertise, information and circumstantial evidence. Police can look at the totality of the circumstances in determining whether they have probable cause. For example, it is perfectly legal to possess plastic baggies, a digital scale, large sums of cash and multiple cell phones. However, if you are pulled over for a valid traffic stop, such as a suspected DUI, and police see all of these items in your vehicle, they could determine that they have probable cause for a search, because these items are indicative of drug trafficking.

You can unwittingly provide the police with probable cause against you. Acting nervous, giving evasive answers or conflicting statements can trigger probable cause when combined with other evidence. The best thing to do is to politely but assertively  tell the police officer that you do not consent to a search and that you would like to speak with an attorney. In addition, tell him that you assert your right to remain silent and will not answer any questions without your attorney present.

Under the Fourth Amendment, these are magic words that cut off the police officers right to question you. Make no mistake, if you are in a situation where a police officer is asking you questions, you are a suspect and you are under investigation. Do not make the incredibly common mistake of incriminating yourself!

Why Assistance of Counsel is So Important

1 Comment »

According to the Sixth Amendment to the US Constitution:

“In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defence.” (Sixth Amendment ratified December 15, 1791.)

The founding fathers believed that it was so important for everyone accused of a crime to have assistance of counsel, that they actually included it in the Sixth Amendment. The reason for that is that we have an adversarial system. The adversarial system is a legal system where represent parties represented by separate advocates who argue their positions before an impartial jury or judge, who are asked to determine the truth of the case based on the facts, law and reason. The adversarial system depends upon both sides having a competent attorney arguing on their behalf.

This means that the prosecution on the other side will be fighting as hard as they can to make sure that you receive the maximum penalty for any crime that you are accused of committing. However, with a strong advocate on your side, you will have someone to challenge the prosecution and make sure that justice is served in your case. By challenging the prosecutions position, you may be able to get your case dismissed, work out a favorable plea bargain, or be acquitted at trial.

What is a Motion to Suppress?

No Comments »

A police officer cannot arrest you, search you or your property, or seize your property unless he has probable cause to do so. Probable cause is generally defined as “facts or evidence that would make a reasonable person believe that a crime or wrongdoing has been, is being, or will be committed.”

A suppression motion is a legal tactic used in criminal defense cases that generally will question whether the arresting officer had probable cause to make a traffic stop or an arrest and seize evidence against you. The suppression hearing is an opportunity for both sides to argue their positions on the motion to suppress to the judge. The judge will consider both the argument of the distract attorney, as well as the defense attorney, and ultimately make a decision as to whether the evidence in the case should be excluded.

If after analyzing the police report and other evidence obtained by our private investigator in preparation for your case, we determine that the police illegally obtained evidence against you, we will file a motion to suppress the evidence, known in California as a 1538.5 motion. The court will then schedule a suppression hearing for your case.

At the suppression hearing, we will contend that the judge must dismiss the evidence against you as a penalty for the police violating your constitutional rights. For a motion to suppress to be granted by the judge, we must prove that the search and/or seizure was illegal by a preponderance of the evidence. If the suppression motion is successful, the prosecution will be left with no evidence against you, and your case will almost certainly be dismissed.

Samantha Ronson Needs a California DUI Defense Attorney

No Comments »

I’ve said before that I don’t spend a lot of time on this site discussing celebrity gossip, but apparently that is not the case, as I’m about to talk about celebrities again. The fact is, celebrities like Lindsay Lohan and Paris Hilton make for great criminal law stories, and people love to read about them.

Case in point, Samantha Ronson, the DJ who dated actress Lindsay Lohan from 2008 to 2009, who was arrested at 10:30 am on August 2nd for DUI. According to police, her blood alcohol level was found to be above .08. Ronson was pulled over doing 90 mph in a 70 and hauled off to San Bernardino County Jail after failing field sobriety tests. Ronson was cooperative enough to make it out of jail by 6 pm, but now she faces a fine of $1,000 and up to 6 months in jail. No doubt she will be lawyering up with a California criminal defense lawyer for her September 23rd hearing!

So how do you know when you need a California DUI lawyer?

  • You are arrested for DUI
  • You were in a car accident caused as a result of your drinking
  • You are in an accident where someone was injured or killed

You should know that you are facing especially serious consequences if :

  • Your BAC was over double the state limit
  • You are facing other charges in addition to the DUI
  • You have one or more other DUIs on your record.

A California criminal defense attorney can help you understand the charges you are facing and aggressively counter them in order to minimize the damage and keep you out of jail.

Do I Have to do the Field Sobriety Tests When I’m Pulled Over for DUI?

No Comments »

Nope.

Many people don’t know this, but the field sobriety tests are entirely optional. Also, field sobriety tests are designed for you to fail, and the science behind them is dubious. Is anyone really good at standing on one leg on the side of the highway and reciting the alphabet backwards? Of course not.

However, if you do choose to take the tests, everything that you say and do is later going to be used against you. Even if we assume that you complete the tests flawlessly, the officer will likely disagree. One day soon, he or she will be in court testifying about how you were swaying, slurring your speech, and generally acting like you were bombed out of your mind. Not good.

So what should you say or do? Here’s my suggestion: “Officer, I know that you are doing your job, but I respectfully decline any field sobriety tests, including the preliminary breathalyzer. I’d like to assert my right to remain silent.” Then, remain silent. If the officer believes he has probable cause to arrest you for DUI without the field sobriety tests, he will then arrest you and take you to the station.

At the station, in the vast majority of cases, it makes sense to take the blood or breath test at the police station or medical center. There are some exceptions, but that’s a topic worthy of another post.

While you probably should take the test at the police station or medical center, that doesn’t mean that you should start talking. Be cooperative and follow their directions, but don’t start talking. They’re still in the process of collecting evidence against you, and anything you say is going to come back to haunt you.

How Do I Fight a California Drug Possession Arrest?

1 Comment »

When a person is arrested on drug possession charges in California, more than anything, they want to know what their options are. Fortunately, in most cases, there are a substantial number of ways to fight the charges and minimize the damage, including contesting the evidence at a suppression hearing and requesting alternative punishments, such as drug treatment programs.

Even when a client is supposedly caught “red handed,” drug possession cases can be fought and won. That’s because the police and their investigators often make critical mistakes. For example, the police may have violated your Fourth Amendment rights against illegal search and seizure. Or they may have lied in order to get a warrant. Perhaps they relied on a questionable confidential informant. Another common mistake is when police arrest people for possession of drugs despite the fact that no evidence exists that the drugs belong to them.

Regardless of your situation, the important thing to remember is to relax and step back for a moment. You’re in a bind that could have life-long repercussions. The best thing you can do is to hire skilled legal counsel to aggressively contest the allegations of the police and district attorney’s office. If the police made any mistakes, we can identify them and use them to put pressure on the prosecution to drop the case or reduce the charges. We also frequently make use of the motion to suppress evidence–when successful, this frequently results in the entire case being dismissed at the suppression hearing.

If you have been arrested on drug possession charges, the police and prosecution are already building their case against you and they have substantial resources. However, with an aggressive attorney on your side, you can turn the situation around and come out clean.

What are the penalties for a first time DUI?

4 Comments »

“I got arrested for DUI. What am I looking at here?”

It’s a question that a California DUI defense attorney is asked fairly frequently. Of course every case is different and the answer depends upon a number of factors. Were there any aggravating factors? Was there an accident? How high was your BAC? An experienced DUI defense attorney is going to ask you all of these questions and much more in order to determine what kind of a case you have. Who knows, perhaps police violated your legal rights and you can get evidence thrown out at the DUI suppression hearing. A skilled attorney will catch such a violation of  your rights immediately.

But for the sake of the question, let’s say we’re talking a simple first time DUI case with no aggravating factors, but nothing to contest at the DUI suppression hearing. DUI is prosecuted under California Vehicle Code VC23152. An arrest for DUI actually creates two separate proceedings against you, known as the “A count” and the “B count.” One is a judicial proceeding and the other is an administrative hearing at the DMV.

san francisco dui defense attorney
If you are convicted on both counts, you’re looking at:

  • Three years of probation
  • A $1200+ fine.
  • Three to four month first offender DUI school
  • Three to five days of sheriff work alternative program
  • Four months DMV drivers license suspension
  • An additional 90 day license restriction

Most people are shocked to learn how serious the legal consequences of a DUI. The penalties above don’t even take into consideration additional consequences, such as being dropped from your insurance, paying significantly higher rates, having a criminal record, social stigma and more. All in all it is overwhelming, especially for those who have never interacted with the criminal justice system before.

Fortunately there is a lot that a skilled DUI defense attorney can do to improve your situation. Motions can be filed. Deals can be made. Your DUI suppression hearing can be won. Cases can be dropped. There are never any guarantees, but a first time DUI is a serious life event, so hire someone that you trust to help you wade through rough waters.

What Do I Do When the Police Are Knocking At My Door?

No Comments »

I’m guessing you ask because you’d rather not invite them inside for tea?

In that case, there are eight steps that you can take that will help when the police are knocking at your door, assuming they don’t already have a warrant or probable cause to enter. If they have that, the game’s already over, sport.

Here is a lesson on what not to do, courtesy of the late Professor Charles Whitebread. He shared a story about his time as a criminal defense attorney. He had a client that greeted the police when they arrived at his house by saying, “You must be here about that Buick I stole!” (The police were there to ask for a donation to their local charity.)

Hopefully you can do better than that.

Here is the reality of the situation: there is only so much that you can do. If the police are intent on coming inside, you can’t physically stop them. Don’t try. But if the police are knocking because they are requesting to speak with you, as opposed to kicking the door down, it’s because they know that they can’t come inside without your permission. (Don’t give it to them.)

So keep it simple:

  1. Check your appearance. Hopefully you don’t look like Gary Busey.
  2. Open the door, step partially out and close the door partially behind you.
  3. Confirm to the police who you are and listen to what they say. Be polite, but don’t be a boot licker.
  4. If they ask you to do something like turn down your stereo, say that you will.
  5. If they ask you to answer questions about any criminal matters, tell them that you could never discuss a criminal matter without your lawyer present.
  6. If they ask to come inside, tell them that you cannot allow that without a warrant.
  7. Regardless of what they say or ask you to do, tell them that you understand that they are just doing their jobs, but that you are busy and would like to return inside.
  8. Ask if you are free to go. Assuming they say yes, say goodbye, go inside and gently lock the door behind you. (Don’t be an ass and slam the door.)

Assuming you can follow these directions, you will avoid giving away the keys to your castle.

Can You Challenge Breathalyzer Accuracy?

34 Comments »

Breathalyzer Accuracy may be challenged in CaliforniaYou probably will be *shocked* to hear that the sobriety test used by the police to establish your blood alcohol level is not perfect. Of course it would make life much easier for the prosecution if the defense could not question the reliability of the sobriety test. In some states, the defense is barred from challenging Breathalyzer accuracy. Fortunately California is not one of those states.

In California, a DUI suspect has a choice between a blood test or a breath test. When it comes to breath tests, the formula used is not accurate for everyone, and varies depending upon a host of factors including: gender, temperature and atmospheric pressure. At least that’s what the pesky scientists say.

 

“Evidence casting doubt on the accuracy of the breath-to-blood conversion ratio is just as relevant as other evidence rebutting the presumption of intoxication from a breath test result, such as evidence that the defendant had a high tolerance for alcohol or performed well in field sobriety testing,” Justice Carol A. Corrigan wrote in a 2009 decision.

If the prosecution wants to put up the results of a breath test device as evidence against you, you are entitled to challenge the accuracy of the sobriety test. The California Supreme Court agrees.

Happy Thanksgiving!

No Comments »

Most people believe that most DUI arrests and accidents happen on New Year’s Eve. However, New Year’s Eve actually runs a distant second: the holiday with the most accidents is actually Thanksgiving. In 2009, nearly 400 people died in Thanksgiving accidents in the U.S. over the five-day holiday and most of the accidents involved alcohol.

So play it safe and don’t take any chances out there this year–if you’ve been drinking, call a cab or sleep it off with a turkey induced coma. There are a lot of options for getting home without drinking. For example, in Northern California, Nevada, and Utah, AAA will tow you and your car home for free. Call 1-800-222-4357 (AAA-HELP) and tell the AAA operator, “I need a Tipsy Tow.”

If you live in another area, check to see if something similar is being offered in an effort to lower instances of drunk driving and DUI arrests.

Have a very happy and safe Thanksgiving!